主席：
Good morning, my dear teacher and clamates.Welcome to listen to our debate.
Books and experience are the main two channels for People to acquire knowledge.Both of them play important roles in our daily life.Some people prefer to read books while others insist that experience is better.Compare knowledge gained from experience with knowledge gained from books.Which is better?
So our topic is: books and experience, which is better method to acquire knowledge?
Before beginning, please allow me to introduce the six debaters to you.###,### and ### stand one the positive side, while ###,### and ### stand on the negative side.Now I formally announce that our debate begins.
First, both side, please state your opinions.
正方陈词：
1.Knowledge can be acquired from many sources.These include books, teachers and practical experience, and each has its own advantages.The knowledge we gain from books enables us to learn about things that we have no opportunity to experience in daily life.We can study all the places in the world and learn from people we will never meet in our lifetime, just by reading about them in books.
2.We can also develop our analytical skills and learn how to view and interpret the world around us in different ways.
3.Furthermore, we can learn from the past by reading books.In this way, we won’t repeat the mistakes of others and can build on their achievements.
反方陈词：
1． Practical experience, on the other hand, can give us more useful knowledge.One can
apply the skills and insights gained through the study of books to practical experience, making them more meaningful.However, unle it is applied to real experiences, book knowledge remains theoretical and, 也就是说, is usele.
2．In addition，knowledge learnt from experience is more unforgettable.It is said
that one learns best by doing, and I believe that this is true, whether one is succeful or not.In fact, I think making mistakes is the best way to learn.
3． Moreover, if one wants to make new advances, it is neceary to act.Innovations
do not come about through read but through experimentation.That is why I believe that knowledge gained from practical experience is more important than that acquired from books.
主席：
Let’s come into the arguing link.Debaters on both sides can ask questions to the opposite side.
反方问题
1.问：
People always are learning and practicing through their whole lives.From reading words in text book such as toy, car, train etc., people have the concept and ideas.They further understand the actual meaning of these words by playing toys and riding or driving cars, trains etc.
答：
没想出来。。。
2.问：
\"The truth comes from practices and experience\"
Experience first can prove if the knowledge from books is true or false.The world is changing everyday, and the theories that are right in past may not suitable to the changed world.And people can only justify them if they are right through practices.A few hundred years ago, people learnt from text book that the earth was flat.However scientists found that was wrong through observations and measurement.
答：
Most is true.因噎废食
3.Stay where we are forever .As books have limitation, they only teach us the what people found in the past.There are a lot new inventions and new products which could not be found from textbooks.Our society and world are developed through continuous practices, those knowledge, never found in books, such as internet, e-busine etc.are all developed through new practices.
答：what we learn from books is the Foundation
正方问题:
1.问：Due to the limitation of objective condition, we can not do whatever we want.It means that we acquire all the knowledge we need from experience.
答：Maybe you are right.But it is also true that Not everything that is learned is contained in books.\" We can not learn something which is beyond description from books.2.
问：Textbooks are very wonderful in teaching people eential principles, how is the world looks like? what is the basic law of change of people and things? We can learn quiet a lot through books .It is efficient ,and can save a lot of time.Can you do all the research in our textbook by your own hand? Do you have enough time?
答：Of course, that is impoible.
Yeah, I admit that I can not do everything on my own.But I think do a perfect job is much better than do hundreds of 勉强的，不够出色的 jobs.
主席：summary
Objectively speaking, as two different learning methods, each of them has advantages and disadvantages.The two of them, which is better? I can not give an exact answer to this question.On one occasion, books are the better choice.However, the answer may be just opposite on another occasion.As a consequence, we should choose the suitable method and make decisions according to different situations.
